Airbrush vs. Brushwork in Modern Abstract Expressionism

Put simply, scale changes the physical act of painting entirely. Time and again, a two or three metre canvas is worked with the whole body, the artist stepping back constantly to read the composition from a distance, sometimes laying the piece flat to pour or pull paint across it. Crucially, managing that scale is a craft in itself, quite apart from the image.

This piece is our full answer to a question collectors ask often: Airbrush vs. Brushwork in Modern Abstract Expressionism. Below we walk through it step by step, with the kind of straight answers we give buyers in the gallery every week, in almost every case. The same thinking guides buyers considering heavy texture palette knife painting online.

Building depth

As a rule, preparation is most of the work, though little of it shows. As a rule, before a mark is made, the canvas is sized and primed, the surface sanded smooth or left with tooth, the paints mixed and tested. Put simply, what looks like a spontaneous gesture usually rests on hours of quiet groundwork.

As a rule, line is the most economical mark an artist owns. In practice, a single continuous contour can suggest a figure, a landscape or pure rhythm with almost nothing on the canvas, which is why line-based abstraction feels so calm and modern. On balance, the discipline lies in knowing when to lift the hand and leave the space empty.

Why artists choose it

Time and again, tools leave signatures. In our experience, a brush, a knife, a rag and a pouring cup each mark the surface in an unmistakable way, and part of learning to read abstract art is learning to see which tool did what. In our experience, once you notice, a painting starts to tell you how it was made.

Naturally, varnish is the final, patient act. More often than not, once the paint has truly cured, a considered varnish protects the surface and unifies its sheen, deepening the blacks and settling the whole image. Time and again, applied too soon it traps soft paint beneath a hard skin, so the best studios simply wait.

Reading the texture

Just as importantly, mixed media simply means combining more than one material in a single work: acrylic with charcoal, ink over texture paste, collage beneath glaze. Naturally, breaking the boundary between painting and other media lets an artist build depth and contrast impossible in one medium alone, and it is a defining feature of much contemporary abstract art.

Put simply, every abstract painting is a sequence of decisions, most of them invisible in the end. Time and again, the artist reacts to what the last mark did, adjusts balance and contrast, covers passages that no longer work, and stops at the point where nothing more can be added or removed. Time and again, what looks spontaneous is usually the survivor of many quiet revisions.

What to notice up close

Time and again, the edge of a painting is a decision too. Crucially, whether a mark runs off the canvas or stops short of it changes how the whole composition breathes, and painters agonise over these boundaries. Just as importantly, a well-judged edge is one of the quiet signs of a mature hand.

The materials behind the look

Naturally, constraint sharpens invention. Naturally, working in strict black and white removes the easiest tool a painter has, which forces every decision onto composition, contrast and surface. As a rule, far from limiting the work, that restriction is what gives monochrome abstraction its particular rigour.

Put simply, line is the most economical mark an artist owns. Put simply, a single continuous contour can suggest a figure, a landscape or pure rhythm with almost nothing on the canvas, which is why line-based abstraction feels so calm and modern. More often than not, the discipline lies in knowing when to lift the hand and leave the space empty.

Living with a worked surface

Naturally, mixed media is about controlled collision. Crucially, charcoal drawn over dried acrylic, ink bleeding into a textured ground, a glaze pulling disparate layers together; each material behaves differently, and the artist choreographs those behaviours into a single coherent surface. Time and again, the depth you sense in a strong mixed media work comes from that layering.

• Palette knife work reads as confident, irreversible gesture.
• Working in black and white forces every decision onto composition and contrast.
• Fluid art is poured and guided rather than brushed, forming cells and ribbons.
• Texture is the honest record of hand and material that no print can copy.

Chance and the balance between them

As a rule, abstract expressionism gave painters permission to make the act of painting the subject. As a rule, sweeping, gestural marks record movement, emotion and energy rather than any object, and the viewer reads the painting as a trace of the moment it was made. More often than not, that legacy still drives much of the expressive, non-figurative work collectors buy today.

More often than not, charcoal and graphite bring drawing into painting. Crucially, worked into or over a painted ground, they add a velvety black and a directness of mark that paint alone cannot give, and they sit naturally within a black and white palette. Time and again, fixed and sealed properly, these drawn passages last as well as the paint around them.

How the method actually works

Put simply, every finished painting hides a hundred that were painted over. Time and again, abstraction is largely an art of revision, of covering, scraping and beginning again until the surface holds. Put simply, the apparent ease of a good canvas is the last and least visible layer of a long argument with the work.

Reader questions